Posts

Writing, Megaliths, and the Silence of the Past

by Robert Arvay This commentary raises questions about the origins of writing, and relates them to the mysteries surrounding ancient megalithic and Egyptian civilizations. It makes forays into speculative but important theories disparaged by many (but not all) accredited scholars. According to conventional historians, writing was invented about six thousand years ago by an ancient civilization known as the Sumerian.  It seems to have been developed abruptly, perhaps within a single generation.  It is as if, one day there was no written language; the next day, there was.  Thereafter, the ability to write, and to read, spread far and wide, enabling civilizations around the world to flourish. There are a few problems with that theory.   Two distinct kinds of writing existed about five to six thousand years ago.   One of them is the phonogram, which is the kind I am using to write this.   The other is the pictogram, or picture-writing, used by the Chine...

Is there any Credible Evidence of a Lost, Technologically Advanced, Worldwide Civilization?

A commentary by Robert Arvay Preface According to a speculative hypothesis, a worldwide civilization once existed that was far more technologically advanced than the present one.   There is little direct physical evidence to support that hypothesis, but a considerable volume of indirect evidence is cited in favor of it by some popularizers.   If the hypothesis is substantially true, then there are significant implications for the future technological advancement of human civilization. Not surprisingly, experts in various relevant fields strongly dispute such speculations, with well-reasoned objections.   For example, this one: “. . . are we to believe that after centuries of flourishing every last tool, potsherd, article of clothing, and, presumably from an advanced civilization, writing, metallurgy and other technologies—not to mention trash—was erased? Inconceivable.”   ( Internet citation:   Scientific American dot com—No, There Wasn't an Advanced Civ...